Pizza restaurants

Pompeii's

4.2 877 reviews 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM 751 Michigan Ave, Baldwin, MI 49304, United States

Discover this place

Pompeii's, nestled in Baldwin, MI, is a charming pizza restaurant that has garnered a variety of reviews. This establishment offers hand-tossed and thin-crust pizzas in multiple sizes, with a build-your-own option featuring a wide range of toppings. Many customers appreciate the friendly service, with reviews highlighting the inviting atmosphere that characterizes this mom-and-pop shop. Sarah enthusiastically shares her experience, saying the pizza was delicious and complimenting the staff’s warmth. Meanwhile, Melissa Oertel notes a noticeable improvement in the pizza's quality, declaring it the best she’s had. The crust and generous toppings shine as a common theme among the praise. Gordon echoes similar sentiments, praising the flavorful crust of his five-meat pizza, while Anna suggests their surprising menu offerings, including burgers. However, not all feedback has been as glowing. Tammy Schipper points out issues with service and consistency, particularly with the sauce-to-cheese ratio on her pizza. She mentions frustrations with phone ordering, which impacted her overall experience. Overall, Pompeii's is a hidden gem in Michigan, reflecting community spirit and culinary satisfaction, though it still has areas for improvement, especially in service speed and consistency. The quality of their pizzas certainly makes it worth a visit, and with continued effort, Pompeii's can elevate its standing even further.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fireplace
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pompeii's before visiting.

Reviews for Pompeii's

4.2

877 reviews

100%

38%

15%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 877 reviews

Pompeii's, a local Italian pizza restaurant in Baldwin, MI, is frequently praised for its delicious, made-from-scratch pizzas with generous toppings and a flavorful crust. Customers appreciate the friendly, welcoming service and the cozy, mom-and-pop atmosphere. The menu variety, including standout specialty pizzas and burgers, is often highlighted as a strength. However, some feedback points to occasional inconsistencies in pizza preparation, such as uneven sauce and cheese distribution. Additionally, there have been complaints regarding difficulties in phone ordering and wait times, suggesting room for improvement in communication and order management. Overall, Pompeii's is valued for its quality food and warm hospitality, with a loyal customer base eager to return.

Sarah

May 31, 2025

First time visiting. Pizza was delicious! Lady up front was super nice! Cute little mom & pop place! Will be back again someday! Thank you!

Tammy Schipper

May 26, 2025

Food is a 4 because the edges of the pizza had so much thick sauce and barely any cheese... Service I gave a 3 because I called for an hour straight and the phone was busy. New year's day was not busy there at all .. I drove into town to place an order for a pizza and a calzone the wait period to place the order. The phone was ringing when I got there. No one answered the phone. As a matter of fact no one started answering the phones until the delivery drivers came back. Which I noticed when I came to pick up my order. The atmosphere needs to be more exciting it's bland I do love Pompeii's. The customer service needs work. And speed of service

Melissa Oertel

Apr 26, 2025

Moved here about year and half ago. We've had pizza here before. I'm not sure what changed. But this last time was the best pizza I've ever had. Keep up the great work!!

Gordon McLellan

Apr 19, 2025

Visited after the very busy first day of the Blessing of the Bikes. I'm thankful they were open late. The staff was friendly and helpful, and the pizza was ready to go quickly. I went with a large five-meat pie. The toppings were generous, and the crust was flavorful without being too thin or too doughy. Looking forward to my next visit.

Anna Chernoby

Apr 13, 2025

Great made from scratch pizzas! The chicken bacon ranch (add pineapple) is my favorite. When I am in the mood for something other than pizza, they have surprisingly great burgers as well.

Dorothy Bragg

Apr 06, 2025

Had Stromboli's delivered and it was delicious

Bill Cleveland

Mar 18, 2025

Pompeii's offers a nice place for lunch in a small town. Service was extremely friendly and attentive. Made a mistake of packaging our meals to go, but we wanted to eat in rather than in the 20F temperatures outside. Food was tasty and provided as expected. Not fancy, but fancy is for big city folk.

Sam Kimmel

Mar 02, 2025

I stopped in by myself today for lunch. The guy up front was friendly and helped me decide on a sandwich and toppings. The food was excellent! It came out quickly, it was hot and delicious. Plenty of meat and toppings too! I'd definitely eat here again. Ps. I got the Pompeii Special (I believe was the name) with mustard and mayo.